AI and its long‑term implications make extreme utilitarian trade‑offs (e.g., future‑people vs present people, insect welfare vs human welfare) practically relevant rather than merely philosophical thought experiments. That pushes utilitarianism from an abstract ethical theory into political conflict over concrete policy (regulation, redistribution, safety priorities).
— If correct, debates about AI policy and funding will increasingly hinge on moral calculus that many voters find counterintuitive, shaping regulation, public trust, and backlash against both technologists and regulators.
Noah Smith
2026.09.22
100% relevant
Noah Smith highlights the Bentham’s Bulldog insect‑vs‑human thought experiment and cites Anthropic/Effective Altruism’s influence in tech as the concrete trigger making these utilitarian dilemmas politically salient.
← Back to all ideas