America’s Tradition: Breaking Tradition

Updated: 2025.08.04 2M ago 2 sources
The author argues that U.S. identity—even in 'trad' communities like the Latter‑day Saints—is built on severing roots and building anew. Pioneer stories valorize choosing an unknown future over returning home, suggesting the 'Retvrn' aesthetic misreads the American lineage. — This reframes today’s traditionalist turn by claiming it conflicts with the core American myth, which prefers forward modernity to ancestral restoration.

Sources

No Retvrn
2025.08.04 100% relevant
Jane Brice’s Martin Handcart saga and her choice to stay in a 'godforsaken desert' rather than go back to England, contrasted with online 'Retvrn' sentiment.
Against Nostalgia
Charles Haywood 2025.06.30 80% relevant
Haywood rejects restorationism ('the arrow of history never points backward') and recounts 1990s conservative nostalgia as strategic failure, aligning with the notion that American vitality comes from founding anew rather than returning to ancestral forms.
← Back to All Ideas