Civil‑service employees use internal discretion, collective resignation threats, or deliberate non‑compliance to block policies they deem immoral, effectively creating a non‑elective 'moral veto' over democratically enacted programs. If institutionalized, this behavior turns administrative competence and rulemaking into arenas for ideological contestation rather than neutral implementation.
— A routinized bureaucratic moral veto would reshape democratic accountability by shifting ultimate policy control from voters and ministers to career officials and networks inside the state.
Matt Goodwin
2026.01.09
100% relevant
Politico reporting (cited in the article) that UK civil servants are discussing quitting or staying to 'blunt' a potential Reform government’s immigration measures; quoted concerns about 'messing with our consciences' exemplify the phenomenon.
← Back to All Ideas