Concept Laundering After Replication

Updated: 2025.09.24 28D ago 1 sources
When famous effects don’t replicate (stereotype threat, ego depletion, implicit bias), psychologists often keep the concepts by redefining them or claiming only the tools failed. Lived experience and 'common sense' then trump null findings, letting theories persist without strong evidence. — This explains why evidence-light ideas continue to shape policy and training, and argues for tighter construct definitions and evidentiary guardrails before institutional adoption.

Sources

Does Data Matter in Psychology?
Michael Inzlicht 2025.09.24 100% relevant
Inzlicht recounts pushback to his doubts about stereotype threat, the watering down of ego depletion to 'mental fatigue,' and Gawronski’s separation of implicit bias concepts from failed measures.
← Back to All Ideas