Court 'Traditionalism' Is Continuity

Updated: 2026.11.17 8H ago 1 sources
A careful review finds that the Supreme Court’s recent appeals to history and 'tradition' are not a clear break or a novel 'classical' jurisprudence but instead a familiar interpretive resource that the Court has long used alongside text and doctrine. The review argues that characterizing the Court as having undergone a distinct traditionalist turn overstates both the novelty and the normative reach of this rhetoric. — Shifts how journalists, advocates, and policymakers should interpret and respond to 'tradition' arguments from the Court: as one input among many rather than a license for sweeping doctrinal overhaul.

Sources

The Court’s Traditionalist Turn?
James R. Rogers 2026.11.17 100% relevant
Marc O. DeGirolami’s book claim (actor) that the Court began an 'incipient traditionalism' in 2021; reviewer James R. Rogers counters using examples from abortion, gun, speech, and religion cases and historical practice.
← Back to all ideas