Arguing that capitalism is a recent 'invention' can be deployed as a political move to delegitimate market institutions and justify large systemic reforms (nationalization, reparative redistribution, or alternative economic orders). The claim’s rhetorical power depends less on detailed history than on its ability to make the current system seem accidental and therefore removable.
— If persuasive, the de‑invention narrative shifts debates from incremental policy reforms to foundational questions of legitimacy and could materially broaden the scope of acceptable economic overhaul.
Steve Sailer
2025.11.30
100% relevant
Sven Beckert’s CAPITALISM: A Global History and its prominent NYT review, and Steve Sailer’s polemic pushback, instantiate how scholarly claims can be translated into public arguments to 'imagine a different and larger world.'
← Back to All Ideas