Don't-Collect Strategy Evades Records Laws

Updated: 2025.10.16 5D ago 3 sources
Agencies can dodge scrutiny by not maintaining basic lists, then deny public-records requests that would require 'compiling or summarizing' data. Alaska’s state police told an Alaska Native nonprofit they don’t keep homicide‑victim lists by race and rejected requests for names, despite public pledges to tackle Missing and Murdered Indigenous People. This tactic turns technical record‑keeping choices into a shield against oversight. — If governments can avoid oversight by choosing not to build datasets, accountability and policy evaluation on crime and race are structurally undermined.

Sources

We Found That More Than 170 U.S. Citizens Have Been Held by Immigration Agents. They’ve Been Kicked, Dragged and Detained for Days.
by Nicole Foy, photography by Sarahbeth Maney 2025.10.16 78% relevant
ProPublica reports DHS does not track how often immigration agents detain U.S. citizens, forcing journalists to build an external tally—mirroring the broader pattern where agencies avoid scrutiny by not maintaining basic datasets.
New Uvalde Records Reveal How the School District Changed Course on Supporting Police Chief
by Lexi Churchill, ProPublica and The Texas Tribune, and Colleen DeGuzman, The Texas Tribune 2025.09.05 65% relevant
Uvalde ISD and the city each withheld or omitted key materials (e.g., 50+ body/dashcam videos; thousands of pages of records) and then trickled them out while blaming 'errors,' functionally achieving the same oversight dodge as not maintaining records in the first place.
Alaska Vowed to Resolve Murders of Indigenous People. Now It Refuses to Provide Their Names.
by Kyle Hopkins, Anchorage Daily News 2025.08.29 100% relevant
Alaska Department of Public Safety’s June rejection of Data for Indigenous Justice’s request for names of homicide victims since 2022, citing a regulation against compiling records.
← Back to All Ideas