Dutch Height: DNA Beats Dairy

Updated: 2025.08.24 1M ago 2 sources
Across 7,884 birth-cohort observations in 146 countries, within-country increases in calories and animal protein raise height, but cross-country differences align far better with a height polygenic score. The Netherlands does not consume exceptional protein or dairy relative to peers like the U.S. or Spain, undermining the dietary myth. Genetics explains the persistent country-level height advantage left over after accounting for nutrition. — This challenges popular diet-based national stereotypes and pushes public health and media toward causal models that include genetic structure when explaining population traits.

Sources

Should Human Biodiversity Be as Respectable as Giraffe Biodiversity?
Steve Sailer 2025.08.24 50% relevant
The giraffe reclassification vs. human‑difference taboo echoes evidence that cross‑population traits (like height) have substantial genetic structure, which public discourse often downplays.
A Cheesy Theory, Debunked: Dutch Height Isn’t About Dairy
Davide Piffer 2025.08.20 100% relevant
Linear mixed-effects models with country random intercepts and a 46-country mapped height PGS show nutrition-only models leave large country effects that the PGS absorbs.
← Back to All Ideas