Emotion programs can increase adolescent risk

Updated: 2026.10.21 1H ago 1 sources
Some school programs that teach emotion regulation and self‑esteem can paradoxically raise substance use and other risky behaviors among adolescents. Randomized evidence (Hansen et al., 1989) shows an emotion‑focused anti‑drug curriculum produced higher cigarette, alcohol and cannabis use versus no program, illustrating that plausible, well‑funded interventions can backfire at scale. — Policymakers and school districts should treat emotion‑focused curricula as testable interventions with potential for harm and demand rigorous randomized evaluation before large rollouts.

Sources

How to get 7th graders to smoke
Seeds of Science 2026.10.21 100% relevant
Hansen et al., 1989 (Project SMART): RCT of ~2,863 Los Angeles junior high students showing the Emotion program increased cigarette, weed, and alcohol use at 12 and 24 month follow‑ups (saliva tests used for verification).
← Back to all ideas