Function‑First Definition of Life

Updated: 2026.11.11 5D ago 3 sources
Life should be defined primarily by functions and organization (information processing, self‑maintenance, goal‑directed behavior) rather than by specific materials or biological substrate. Under this view, sufficiently complex technologies could be considered 'life‑like' if they perform the same functional roles. — If accepted, this framing shifts public debates about AI rights, biosecurity, and regulation by collapsing the categorical wall between 'organic' life and engineered systems.

Sources

Decoding Ediacaran fossils
Aeon Video 2026.11.11 75% relevant
The video foregrounds functional evidence (movement, lateral bias) as the basis for identifying early animals rather than molecular or modern‑body criteria, echoing a 'function‑first' approach to defining life and informing how palaeontologists and astrobiologists infer life from sparse traces; key elements are Scott Evans' Nilpena fieldwork and his claim that Ediacaran taxa show movement and handedness.
The origin of the universe is easier to explain than the origin of life
Paul Davies 2026.11.10 75% relevant
Davies emphasizes that physics as currently formulated explains cosmic origins well but does not account for the functional, information‑rich organization that marks life; this connects to the 'function‑first' framing which treats life as defined by organized function/information rather than just chemistry, and signals the need for new principles or theoretical categories to explain abiogenesis (actor: Paul Davies; claim: laws of physics insufficient to explain origin of life).
Google CTO: A unifying theory of life, intelligence, and technology
Steph McClain 2026.10.02 100% relevant
Blaise Agüera y Arcas’ Big Think interview, where he advocates treating function as the defining criterion for life and links that to intelligence and technology.
← Back to all ideas