Goodness‑First Moral Heuristic

Updated: 2026.01.08 21D ago 1 sources
Treat public moral reasoning as guided by a simple operational rule: default to actions that favor pluralist, liberal‑democratic outcomes and oppose actions that clearly entrench oppression or falsehood. This heuristic doesn’t substitute for argumentation but provides a practical, transparent decision rule when ideological packages produce contradictory demands. — Making a compact 'goodness‑first' heuristic explicit helps citizens and policymakers adjudicate messy foreign‑policy and ethical tradeoffs, reduces reflexive package‑labeling, and supplies an audit‑able anchor for public debate.

Sources

The Goodness Cluster
Scott 2026.01.08 100% relevant
Aaronson’s repeated formulation—'I’m in favor of good things, and against bad things' and his example of respecting democratic choices in Venezuela, Greenland, Ukraine and Taiwan—provides the concrete utterance that this idea operationalizes.
← Back to All Ideas