Goodreads Mobs Censor Books Pre-Release

Updated: 2025.10.07 15D ago 2 sources
Coordinated low‑star ratings and social‑media pile‑ons on Goodreads can kill a book before it reaches stores. Publishers and authors preemptively revise, delay, or cancel to avoid sales risk, even when accusations are about setting or character politics rather than content quality. This shifts editorial control from professionals to crowd campaigns. — It shows how platform crowd power governs cultural speech upstream of the market and the state, narrowing what ideas reach print.

Sources

The Unfree Press
Adam Szetela 2025.10.07 82% relevant
Szetela describes books being canceled before publication after online campaigns labeled them racist/sexist/transphobic, mirroring platform‑led pre‑market censorship dynamics highlighted in the Goodreads‑mob idea.
Why today’s publishers fear Goodreads more than government
Kevin Dickinson 2025.09.02 100% relevant
Sophie Lark’s novel was canceled after backlash; Elizabeth Gilbert delayed her Russia‑set book following a wave of one‑star Goodreads reviews; Amélie Wen Zhao revised Blood Heir after online accusations.
← Back to All Ideas