High Pay, Small State Paradox

Updated: 2025.08.27 1M ago 2 sources
In some poorer countries, inflated public salaries attract huge applicant queues but shrink actual headcount because budgets can’t support many hires. The result is both misallocated talent and understaffed agencies—e.g., India has 'all the laws of a rich country' with roughly one‑fifth the civil servants per capita. High pay thus weakens state capacity while draining private productivity. — It reframes civil‑service reform by showing that mispriced wages can produce a weaker, not larger, state alongside growth losses.

Sources

Singapore’s Pay Model Isn’t India’s: Market Wages vs. Civil-Service Rents
Alex Tabarrok 2025.08.27 80% relevant
It reinforces how inflated public wages can both shrink actual state capacity and misallocate talent, while noting Singapore avoids the paradox by paying market rates broadly and only de-compressing at the very top.
India, Greece, Brazil: How High Government Pay Wastes Talent and Drains Productivity
Alex Tabarrok 2025.08.25 100% relevant
The article’s claim that 'India has all the laws of a rich country with roughly one‑fifth the civil servants per capita' due to high salaries limiting staffing.
← Back to All Ideas