High spending doesn’t guarantee better schools

Updated: 2026.03.05 3H ago 1 sources
State-by-state NAEP data show some low‑spending states (e.g., Mississippi, Louisiana) ranking at or near the top after demographic adjustment, while very high‑spending systems like New York are only modestly above average. That suggests the policy problem is not only 'raise more money' but 'get better value from existing spending' and consider local tax‑politics constraints on funding increases. — Shifts the debate from ‘more money’ to ‘how money is used’ and whether progressive tax proposals that assume mobile elites can be applied at state and local scales.

Sources

Is a new teacher better off in Mississippi than in New York?
Matthew Yglesias 2026.03.05 100% relevant
The article cites Urban Institute demographically adjusted NAEP scores where Mississippi ranks first in eighth‑grade math and high spending New York is not top, and notes marginal, targeted investments (HVAC) can help even where aggregate spending is high.
← Back to All Ideas