Not all beliefs are alike: action‑guiding 'regular' beliefs feel forced by reality, while 'credences' are chosen and often serve as social signals. A practical test for credibility is whether someone seems dragged 'kicking and screaming' to a conclusion rather than eagerly adopting it because it fits their group. Use this cue first on yourself to avoid turning it into a cheap dismissal of rivals.
— This heuristic gives citizens, editors, and policymakers a concrete way to sort sincere claims from performative signaling in public debate.
David Pinsof
2024.10.15
100% relevant
Pinsof’s proposal to assess how 'involuntary' a belief appears—versus being conveniently chosen—when judging whether it’s 'bullshit.'
← Back to All Ideas