A judge’s public reserve, avoidance of spectacle, and focus on procedural modesty function as an institutional stabilizer: by not seeking the spotlight, a jurist preserves court legitimacy, reduces perception of partisanship, and makes the institution less vulnerable to politicized attacks.
— If judges and other officials adopt and signal this temperament, it reduces political polarization around courts, improves public trust in adjudication, and constrains cycles of retributive lawfare.
Andy Smarick
2026.01.15
100% relevant
Andy Smarick’s review of Amy Coney Barrett’s Listening to the Law emphasizes Barrett’s consistent restraint—minimal personal anecdotes, avoidance of theatricality, judicial‑style prose—as evidence that temperament itself is a policy‑relevant institutional tool.
← Back to All Ideas