Liberal Ends, Illiberal Means

Updated: 2025.09.07 1M ago 2 sources
American liberal achievements often relied on illiberal actions—Lincoln’s suspension of habeas corpus, FDR’s court‑packing push, and WWII firebombing—all cited as necessary but not 'liberal' methods. Seeing U.S. history as a union of liberal and illiberal forces suggests today’s illiberal episodes are cyclical, not a decisive break. This lens challenges simple declinist or panic narratives. — It urges analysts and voters to judge 'authoritarianism' claims against a historical baseline where liberal victories frequently used illiberal tools, refining how we assess institutional risk today.

Sources

Three accounts of modern liberalism
Tyler Cowen 2025.09.07 100% relevant
Cowen’s review passage: 'Once we see American history as a union of liberal and illiberal forces, we can relax a little about the current situation,' with concrete examples (Lincoln, FDR, Tokyo firebombing).
The Fate of Liberal Neutrality
Damon Linker 2025.08.15 60% relevant
Linker’s defense of rule‑of‑law neutrality highlights the tension that the 'Liberal Ends, Illiberal Means' entry raises: liberal orders celebrate neutral rules, yet historically they’ve sometimes relied on illiberal tactics, a contradiction that can fuel today’s cynicism about neutrality.
← Back to All Ideas