Liberalism’s Identity Self‑Undermining

Updated: 2026.01.12 17D ago 1 sources
When mainstream liberal institutions and elites organize moral assessment primarily through group categories rather than individual adjudication, they risk eroding the liberal commitments (universal individual rights, procedural fairness) that underpin broad coalitions. That strategic framing can convert principled anti‑racism into a political-identity litmus test that narrows persuasion, fuels backlash, and weakens institutional legitimacy. — If true, the idea reframes debates about anti‑racist strategy, university governance, and progressive policy from purely normative disputes to concrete questions about coalition maintenance, messaging, and institutional design.

Sources

What went wrong with modern liberalism? (w/ Matthew Yglesias)
Jerusalem Demsas 2026.01.12 100% relevant
Matthew Yglesias’s argument on The Argument podcast (Jerusalem Demsas host, Jan 12, 2026) that liberals undermined their own principles by shifting to group‑based moral sorting directly exemplifies this dynamic.
← Back to All Ideas