Loans Hurt Optimistic Low‑Skill Students

Updated: 2026.03.31 1H ago 1 sources
New empirical work shows that beliefs about the probability of finishing a bachelor’s degree predict who enrolls, and that widespread optimism can make access to federal student loans welfare‑reducing for low‑skill, poor students who overestimate their chances. The paper models college as a risky investment and finds that loan availability amplifies the cost of mistaken beliefs. — If replicated, this challenges the simple assumption that broader access to federal loans is always welfare‑improving and should reshape debates over loan eligibility, counseling, and targeting.

Sources

The economics of dropout risk
Tyler Cowen 2026.03.31 100% relevant
AEJ: Macroeconomics paper by Emily G. Moschini, Gajendran Raveendranathan, and Ming Xu showing belief distributions predict enrollment and that loan access can reduce welfare for low‑skill, optimistic young adults.
← Back to All Ideas