Lockable phone pouches curb phones, not learning

Updated: 2026.05.05 1H ago 1 sources
A nationwide, staggered difference‑in‑differences study finds that school adoption of lockable phone pouches sharply reduces measured phone use but yields near‑zero average test‑score effects; short‑term discipline and well‑being worsen before later normalization and modest heterogenous effects (small gains in high‑school math, slight harms in middle school). — Shows that popular school phone bans can change behaviour without producing the large academic improvements that many advocates promise, so policy debates should focus on tradeoffs and implementation rather than moral urgency.

Sources

The best study to date on school phone bans
Tyler Cowen 2026.05.05 100% relevant
NBER working paper by Allcott, Baron, Dee, Duckworth, Gentzkow and Jacob using GPS pings, teacher reports, test scores, administrative records, and sales data for pouch provider.
← Back to All Ideas