Machiavellian roots of rational control

Updated: 2026.04.02 7H ago 1 sources
Mansfield argues that Machiavelli’s break with ancient and medieval political thought planted the intellectual seed for a modern project of ‘rational control’—a tendency in later thinkers to systematize and then try to fix the political consequences of earlier fixes. The book traces how Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, Kant, Hegel, Marx and Nietzsche each advance-and-correct that project, producing modern dilemmas about power, authority, and technocratic governance. — This genealogy reframes contemporary disputes over executive power, technocracy, and political realism as the long-term aftereffects of a single intellectual turning point, shifting focus from isolated policy fights to deep philosophical lineage.

Sources

Mansfield’s Machiavellian Modernity
David Lewis Schaefer 2026.04.02 100% relevant
The review summarizes Mansfield’s central thesis and textbook scope (Machiavelli through Nietzsche) from his book The Rise and Fall of Rational Control and highlights Mansfield’s Straussian lineage and Harvard authority as transmitter and amplifier of the idea.
← Back to All Ideas