Agustina S. Paglayan’s book argues governments adopted mass education primarily to produce obedient citizens, not to expand autonomy. She cites the timing of adoption, the rhetoric that persuaded rulers, and the training/directives given to teachers as evidence of an indoctrination aim. This challenges the romantic story of schooling as a pure emancipation project.
— It reframes education policy debates by suggesting centralization and curriculum battles are features of state power, not bugs, with implications for governance, school choice, and civic formation.
Arnold Kling
2025.09.02
100% relevant
Arnold Kling’s review of Paglayan’s 'Raised to Obey' highlighting evidence on timing, political arguments, and teacher training used to justify and implement mass education.
← Back to All Ideas