MI5 Admits Unlawful Journalist Surveillance

Updated: 2025.10.16 5D ago 2 sources
MI5 told the Investigatory Powers Tribunal that it unlawfully obtained communications data from former BBC journalist Vincent Kearney in 2006 and 2009, breaching European Convention on Human Rights Articles 8 and 10. Counsel said it appears to be the first time MI5 has publicly acknowledged interfering with a journalist’s communications data. The case stems from scrutiny of police and intelligence access to reporters’ data in Northern Ireland. — An unprecedented admission by a security agency intensifies the debate over press protections, investigatory powers, and accountability mechanisms for intelligence services.

Sources

Westminster’s China blind spot
Dominic Adler 2025.10.16 43% relevant
Both highlight accountability gaps in the UK’s security ecosystem: the article alleges politicized, selective enforcement (e.g., CPS refusal to charge in the Shayler leak) while the MI5 case shows formal admission of rights violations—together suggesting systemic opacity and uneven standards.
UK's MI5 'Unlawfully' Obtained Data From Former BBC Journalist
BeauHD 2025.09.16 100% relevant
MI5’s letter and tribunal filings acknowledging unlawful acquisition of Kearney’s phone data (2006, 2009) and ECHR violations.
← Back to All Ideas