Milton’s Curse of Speech Hypocrisy

Updated: 2025.10.07 15D ago 1 sources
Free speech is inherently hard to uphold consistently; even canonical defenders like John Milton carved out exceptions. Jacob Mchangama labels this recurrent pattern 'Milton’s Curse,' arguing that hypocrisy is a feature of human nature and political coalitions, not an aberration. The practical task is expanding the circle of tolerated speech over time despite that bias. — This framing equips policymakers and institutions to expect and mitigate partisan double standards in speech debates rather than treating each episode as novel bad faith.

Sources

The Good Fight Club: Who’s a Hypocrite About Free Speech?
Yascha Mounk 2025.10.07 100% relevant
Mchangama’s remark that 'we are all hypocrites about free speech,' illustrated by Milton’s Areopagitica excluding Catholics and blasphemy.
← Back to All Ideas