Immigration policy debates are increasingly being decided not by narrow economic metrics but by an explicit civic‑identity test: politicians and commentators frame newcomers in terms of whether they 'fit' a national story, and that framing reshapes who is deemed deserving, what integration means, and which policies gain political traction.
— If civic identity becomes the primary lens for immigration policy, technical debates about visas, labor markets, and enforcement will be subordinated to contested narratives about cultural continuity and belonging.
Christopher F. Rufo
2025.12.03
100% relevant
Rufo’s repeated foregrounding of ‘what does it mean to be an American,’ his citation of post‑1965 foreign‑born totals (≈53 million), and his invocation of historical comparators (1920/1924 pause) concretely illustrate the idea.
← Back to All Ideas