Critics sometimes rebut a study not by disputing its data or methods, but by pointing out things it did not study — treating any omitted variable as a de facto refutation. That move is rhetorical, not methodological: every empirical study omits many things, so arguing 'you didn’t study X therefore your Y finding is invalid' is a logical non sequitur that shifts the debate away from evidence.
— Calling out this rhetorical pattern matters because it clarifies public evaluation of research, reduces bad‑faith dismissal of inconvenient results, and raises the bar for media and policy commentaries that should address what a study actually tested.
Lee Jussim
2026.11.18
100% relevant
Lee Jussim’s on‑record rebuttal to Guardian and campus coverage that attacked his team's report by saying it failed to include other measures (e.g., different targets for political violence or right‑wing measures) is the concrete example of this tactic.
← Back to all ideas