Publishing code and raw item responses lets independent researchers recompute factor analyses and catch impossible or fabricated statistics — in this case identical .742 loadings across ten items. When authors omit basic descriptives and withhold actual loadings, obvious problems can be hidden behind jargon or compositing claims.
— If journals and funders require code and basic descriptive reporting, many clear statistical impossibilities and possible frauds can be detected and corrected before they distort public debates.
José Duarte
2026.03.09
100% relevant
José Duarte posted R and SPSS code plus the dataset for Lewandowsky et al. (2012) and demonstrates that the paper’s table of identical factor loadings (.742) cannot be reproduced and likely is false.
← Back to All Ideas