PBIS Entrenches Weak School Discipline

Updated: 2025.08.21 2M ago 1 sources
PBIS is sold as a neutral management system, but in practice it biases schools toward rewards and away from consequences. Its flexibility and federal backing let districts avoid punitive measures without naming that choice, weakening teacher authority and fueling disorder and burnout. Because it dominates U.S. discipline policy, the effect scales nationally. — This shifts the school-discipline debate from blaming 'restorative justice' to examining PBIS’s design and federal sponsorship as drivers of classroom chaos and learning loss.

Sources

The High Costs of Classroom Disorder
Neetu Arnold 2025.08.21 100% relevant
The article notes a U.S. Department of Education–funded PBIS center, PBIS trainers’ anti‑punitive stance, and teacher accounts (e.g., Ben Foley) of 'anarchic' classrooms under PBIS.
← Back to All Ideas