PISA‑D’s stark Africa–U.S. gap

Updated: 2025.09.28 23D ago 2 sources
Because PISA‑D is calibrated to the main PISA scale, Zambia’s 275 average versus U.S. Black students’ 459 implies about a 1.8 standard‑deviation difference in reading. That magnitude suggests schooling quality and broader environment drive much of the disparity, not ancestry alone. It reframes how we compare U.S. subgroup performance to developing countries. — It injects hard numbers into contentious education and heredity debates while highlighting the scale of global human‑capital deficits.

Sources

How Low You Can Go in the Third World
Steve Sailer 2025.09.28 100% relevant
NCES 2022 PISA reading (Black students 459) and Zambia’s PISA‑D 275 across 5,273 students in 200 schools; author’s ~1.84 SD calculation and comment that 'genes aren’t everything.'
Zambia fact of the day
Tyler Cowen 2025.09.28 85% relevant
The post cites a dramatic PISA-based proficiency figure for Zambia that aligns with the broader finding that many African systems score far below U.S. subgroups on PISA/PISA‑D scales, underscoring the magnitude of global human‑capital gaps.
← Back to All Ideas