Policing pullback explains 2020 homicides

Updated: 2026.01.12 16D ago 4 sources
A plausible account for the dramatic 2020 increase in urban shootings is a rapid change in policing practice and deterrence following late‑May protests (e.g., after George Floyd’s death), rather than seasonal weather, lockdowns, or gun purchases alone. That hypothesis stresses timing (surge beginning the last week of May), concentration (large cities, shootings vs. other street crime), and mechanism (reduced proactive enforcement and deterrence), and is empirically testable with arrest, deployment, and incident‑level data. — If true, it changes policy remedies from only addressing gun access or economic conditions to recalibrating urban policing tactics, deployment strategies, and accountability frameworks in ways that affect minority‑neighborhood safety.

Sources

Why Jonathan Ross was legally justified in shooting Renée Good
eugyppius 2026.01.12 62% relevant
While not directly about the 2020 spike, the article’s central claim (that protest dynamics alter policing latitude and outcomes) maps to the broader pattern that changes in policing posture and public‑order signals can produce measurable shifts in lethal violence and enforcement outcomes.
Who We Are: Crime and Public Safety
Rafael A. Mangual, Heather Mac Donald 2026.01.07 78% relevant
The podcast advances the Manhattan Institute’s public‑order argument (Broken Windows, deterrence) and critiques progressive policing. That directly connects to the existing idea that changes in policing practice/deterrence explain recent homicide trends; the actor (Heather Mac Donald) is a prominent proponent of this explanation and the episode explicitly links mayoral policy choices to daily safety outcomes.
30 months of great news on falling crime
2026.01.05 90% relevant
Yglesias cites the 2020 spike and the subsequent 30‑month decline while noting mechanisms (detective time, patrol availability) that align with the existing idea that changes in policing practices and deterrence plausibly drove the initial rise and the later fall; both pieces emphasize timing, city‑level deployment, and the need for detailed deployment/arrest data to test causality.
What Caused Last Year’s Spike in Violent Crime? | The Heritage Foundation
2026.01.05 100% relevant
Paul Cassell law‑review synthesis cited in the article; Gun Violence Archive national counts (~19,000 gun deaths in 2020); city examples (Minneapolis +95% May–Aug, Chicago doubling in July, NYC 50% homicide increase) and the surge’s start date (last week of May, post‑George Floyd).
← Back to All Ideas