A visible clash between Pope Leo XIV and postliberal Catholic critics (and sympathetic U.S. politicians) is exposing a deeper split in conservative Catholicism: one side ties religious authority to universal moral claims (opposition to war), the other privileges national loyalties and a politics of cultural identity. That dispute is shifting who counts as the moral arbiter for conservative foreign‑policy and domestic coalitions.
— If postliberal Catholics break from neoconservative patriotism, conservative coalitions, voting blocs, and foreign‑policy rhetoric could realign around different moral authorities and priorities.
James M. Patterson
2026.04.24
100% relevant
Sohrab Ahmari’s UnHerd essay blaming Catholic neoconservatives, the pope’s April 11 homily warning against the 'delusion of omnipotence,' and President Trump’s reactive Truth Social post about the homily.
← Back to All Ideas