Pottery‑study myth traced to photography

Updated: 2026.11.03 11H ago 1 sources
A widely‑cited 'experiment' comparing quantity‑vs‑quality in pottery is not a randomized study but an anecdote from the book Art & Fear; the book's authors later admitted the story originally concerned a photography class (Jerry Uelsmann) and was retold without methodological detail. The result commonly quoted as evidence for 'produce more to improve' therefore rests on an undocumented anecdote, not verifiable data. — It warns that commonly used 'empirical' anecdotes in culture and pedagogy debates can be provenance‑free myths, so public arguments built on them are fragile and should be retraced.

Sources

Quantity vs quality in pottery is a lie
becausecurious 2026.11.03 100% relevant
Art & Fear (page 29), authors David Bayles and Ted Orland's 2016 email admissions, and Jerry Uelsmann as the original teacher referenced.
← Back to all ideas