Preinstall Mandates Backfire in India

Updated: 2025.12.03 2D ago 1 sources
India issued a secret directive requiring phone makers to ship iPhones and others with a government app preinstalled and non‑removable, then rescinded it within a week after privacy uproar and vendor resistance. The episode produced a spike in user registrations from the controversy and left civil‑society groups demanding formal legal clarifications before trusting future moves. — This episode is an early, concrete sample of how states try to convert devices into governance instruments and how public backlash, privacy concerns, and platform leverage can force reversals — a pattern that will shape digital sovereignty debates worldwide.

Sources

India Pulls Its Preinstalled iPhone App Demand
BeauHD 2025.12.03 100% relevant
India Ministry of Communication’s secret November 28 directive, the Sanchar Saathi app requirement, rapid withdrawal, Minister Scindia’s statements denying surveillance risk, and Internet Freedom Foundation’s demand for the legal order.
← Back to All Ideas