Instead of ranking colleges mainly by prestige and selectivity, evaluate them on governance, academic standards, campus norms, and civic formation — measurable indicators like presence/absence of DEI offices, faculty‑hiring practices, admissions testing policies, and protections for viewpoint diversity. Such a ranking highlights institutional responsibility for students’ intellectual formation and helps families choose schools aligned with civic and career outcomes.
— Shifting the ranking axis from selectivity to governance reframes debates about higher education legitimacy, accountability, and public funding priorities.
Kevin Wallsten
2026.11.09
100% relevant
City Journal scored 115 colleges on 95 variables (governance, educational experience, student life, career outcomes), reporting an average score of 50/100 and noting trends like reinstated testing and DEI rollbacks as concrete markers.
← Back to all ideas