Redirect Ambition, Don't Abolish Profit

Updated: 2026.11.12 49MIN ago 1 sources
Ambition and the pursuit of status are ineradicable human motives; outlawing profit‑seeking simply shifts those motives into other, often hidden or more destructive, currencies (virtue, patronage, factional prestige). Public policy should therefore focus on channeling and reshaping incentives — changing rules, ownership, and accountability — rather than attempting to eliminate ambition or profit per se. — If correct, this shifts debates from abolitionist rhetoric (ban profit) to practical design questions (how to rechannel ambition through governance, taxation, ownership structures, and reputational institutions).

Sources

You Can’t Abolish The Profit Motive
Dan Williams 2026.11.12 100% relevant
The article’s concrete observation that far‑left organizations replace monetary profit with a reputational currency (examples: factional splits, the new 'Your Party' rapid fragmentation) exemplifies how anti‑profit projects reorient ambition into status markets.
← Back to all ideas