Religious Drift as Adaptive Lottery

Updated: 2026.04.28 1M ago 3 sources
When a dominant religion or creed drifts in a large, peaceful society, most changes are maladaptive but occasionally enable rare large‑scale social jumps (e.g., tolerance + individualism → capitalism). Policymakers should treat religious and cultural drift as a high‑variance process—one that can produce both collapse risks and occasional transformative luck—rather than as steadily progressive or regressive. — This reframes debates over secularization, reform, and cultural engineering: rather than assuming steady improvement, societies must manage drift, preserve variation, and avoid relying on a chance beneficial reversal.

Sources

On Demons
Alan Schmidt 2026.04.28 65% relevant
The author interprets growing demand for exorcists and renewed interest in spiritual explanations as part of a broader shift in religiosity and meaning‑seeking after decades of materialist ascendancy, connecting individual cases to a population‑level religious drift described by this idea.
Why British Women Are Converting to Islam
Julie Bindel 2026.04.23 60% relevant
Bindel presents conversion to Islam among British women as part of a broader drift in religious affiliation driven by social needs (meaning, cohesion), which maps onto the notion that religious change can be an adaptive, contingent cultural shift rather than purely doctrinal — the article supplies anecdotal evidence (Aisha/Max) that exemplifies that drift.
Christian Cultural Drift
Robin Hanson 2026.01.07 100% relevant
Robin Hanson’s essay: he argues Christianity’s long sequence of drift (monastic land accumulation, religious wars, then surprising tolerance after 1648) created the contingent conditions for capitalism—an example of the 'adaptive lottery' thesis.
← Back to all ideas