Moral renunciation (e.g., rejecting ownership) can be adopted as a status signal and then institutionalized by elite actors, who strip it of its original egalitarian bite while keeping its prestige value. Over time institutions convert radical gestures into assets (patronage, buildings, rules) that preserve hierarchy rather than abolish it.
— This reframes current debates about virtue signalling, philanthropy, and property by showing a historical mechanism through which radical moral postures are domesticated and used to manage social order.
Simon Critchley
2026.10.06
100% relevant
Simon Critchley’s account: Francis strips naked in the piazza (gesture of renunciation), the friars later accept land and patron burials, and the Basilica is built — concrete chain from radical act to elite appropriation.
← Back to all ideas