Responsible Autonomy as Policy

Updated: 2026.09.13 1D ago 1 sources
Treat free will as a matter of degree—'responsible autonomy'—so policy, law and social praise/blame are calibrated to an individual's capacity (child, addicted person, psychotic offender, functioning adult). This reframing rejects both hard determinism and naive libertarian voluntarism and makes responsibility a practical variable for courts, schools and social programs. — If adopted, it changes how we assign legal blame, design rehabilitation, and talk about elites' moral responsibility versus excuses for criminal behavior.

Sources

Apparently Criminals Don’t Have Free Will, But Elites Do
Rob Henderson 2026.09.13 100% relevant
Uses Roy Baumeister’s phrase 'responsible autonomy' and the article’s critique of Sapolsky/Harris to argue policy should distinguish degrees of freedom (e.g., addiction, rage, planning) rather than rely on categorical claims that undermine accountability.
← Back to all ideas