Treat free will as a matter of degree—'responsible autonomy'—so policy, law and social praise/blame are calibrated to an individual's capacity (child, addicted person, psychotic offender, functioning adult). This reframing rejects both hard determinism and naive libertarian voluntarism and makes responsibility a practical variable for courts, schools and social programs.
— If adopted, it changes how we assign legal blame, design rehabilitation, and talk about elites' moral responsibility versus excuses for criminal behavior.
Rob Henderson
2026.09.13
100% relevant
Uses Roy Baumeister’s phrase 'responsible autonomy' and the article’s critique of Sapolsky/Harris to argue policy should distinguish degrees of freedom (e.g., addiction, rage, planning) rather than rely on categorical claims that undermine accountability.
← Back to all ideas