Ritual Diplomacy Without Power

Updated: 2025.09.10 1M ago 4 sources
European leaders and media issue moralistic 'five-point' plans and declarations as if repetition can determine war outcomes, despite lacking leverage over Russia. This norms-first posture can worsen Ukraine’s bargaining position as battlefield losses continue. It spotlights a governance style that confuses performative unity with coercive capacity. — If Western institutions keep replacing power with proclamations, foreign policy will underperform and produce harsher endgames for client states.

Sources

Netanyahu’s deadly gamble
David Patrikarakos 2025.09.10 60% relevant
The article shows rapid, norms‑first condemnations (UN, Turkey, Germany) after the Doha strike without obvious leverage to alter Israeli behavior, illustrating the pattern where declaratory diplomacy substitutes for coercive capacity.
Europe is stuck in the Total Perspective Vortex
Wolfgang Munchau 2025.08.25 70% relevant
The seating‑photo vignette of EU leaders 'like unruly schoolchildren' underscores that norms-first posturing collapses without leverage; the U.S. 'put a gun on the table' and Europe conceded—matching the thesis that declaratory diplomacy cannot substitute for coercive capacity.
The European press are having a big stroppy sad following the Trump-Putin summit in Alaska
eugyppius 2025.08.16 100% relevant
Friedrich Merz’s pre‑summit 'five points' alongside Süddeutsche Zeitung’s calls for unity contrasted with Russia’s ongoing advances and Trump’s shift toward a comprehensive 'peace agreement.'
The Euro-American Split (I): Dread Possibility
T. Greer 2025.02.21 62% relevant
The article amplifies the claim that Europe relies on norms and declarations while lacking hard power by invoking Gates’s warning that declining European defense effort would sap U.S. patience for NATO, pushing the alliance toward fracture when moral suasion isn’t backed by capabilities.
← Back to All Ideas