Robot Umpires Replace Negotiated Fairness

Updated: 2025.10.01 21D ago 1 sources
The piece argues the strike zone has always been a relational, fairness‑based construct negotiated among umpire, pitcher, and catcher rather than a fixed rectangle. Automating calls via robot umpires swaps that lived symmetry for technocratic precision that changes how the game is governed. — It offers a concrete microcosm for debates over algorithmic rule‑enforcement versus human discretion in institutions beyond sports.

Sources

The Disenchantment of Baseball
Nick Burns 2025.10.01 100% relevant
MLB’s September 23 announcement introducing robot umpires with a limited challenge system for balls and strikes in the 2026 season.
← Back to All Ideas