A mayoral office can convert FOIL's request‑specific timing rules into a blanket six‑month response schedule, effectively turning formal acknowledgement into routine delay. City Journal examined the city's OpenRecords portal and found the Mayor’s Office assigned roughly six‑month response dates to 88.7% of requests in a recent period, prompting the Manhattan Institute to sue.
— If replicated, this administrative tactic would hollow out public‑records laws, making timely scrutiny of government conduct impractical and shifting how journalists, watchdogs, and courts enforce transparency.
Santiago Vidal Calvo, Cameron Macdonald
2026.09.15
100% relevant
Manhattan Institute FOIL request about Commissioner Ana Maria Archila; the Mayor’s Office replied with a January 11, 2027 date for a July 9 request, and portal data show 220/248 requests assigned six‑month dates.
← Back to all ideas