Six‑Month FOIL Waiting Periods

Updated: 2026.09.15 5H ago 1 sources
A mayoral office can convert FOIL's request‑specific timing rules into a blanket six‑month response schedule, effectively turning formal acknowledgement into routine delay. City Journal examined the city's OpenRecords portal and found the Mayor’s Office assigned roughly six‑month response dates to 88.7% of requests in a recent period, prompting the Manhattan Institute to sue. — If replicated, this administrative tactic would hollow out public‑records laws, making timely scrutiny of government conduct impractical and shifting how journalists, watchdogs, and courts enforce transparency.

Sources

Mamdani Has a Transparency Problem. We’re Suing to Fix It.
Santiago Vidal Calvo, Cameron Macdonald 2026.09.15 100% relevant
Manhattan Institute FOIL request about Commissioner Ana Maria Archila; the Mayor’s Office replied with a January 11, 2027 date for a July 9 request, and portal data show 220/248 requests assigned six‑month dates.
← Back to all ideas