People can hold nuanced, mixed judgments about others, but social incentives—fear of being seen as morally soft or of siding with the wrong group—push public speech into binary labels: villain or victim. This dynamic makes moral nuance costly and drives collective demand for simple moral narratives even when individuals privately accept complexity.
— If social pressure systematically silences nuance, public debate will favor punitive, polarized policies and symbolic morality over pragmatic problem‑solving across justice, media, and political institutions.
Paul Bloom
2026.11.16
100% relevant
Paul Bloom and Azim Shariff's Small Potatoes followup to their New Yorker piece cites cases (9/11, incels, abused abusers) and Jillian Jordan's observation that people afford nuance to fictional characters but not to real people, illustrating the social‑speech explanation.
← Back to all ideas