The 1970s–80s sociobiology controversy provides a recurring playbook for how intra‑academic disputes escalate into public 'cancellations'—actors, tactics (petitioning, reputational pressure), and institutional dynamics repeat across eras. Studying the original episode gives a diagnostic framework for diagnosing and responding to contemporary campus conflicts.
— If treated as a template, policymakers and university leaders can design procedures (transparent review, protected debate forums, clearer standards for sanctions) that prevent procedural silence from functioning as de facto censorship.
Razib Khan
2026.01.01
100% relevant
Razib Khan cites Ullica Segerstråle’s Defenders of the Truth and draws a direct parallel between the Wilson–Lewontin disputes and recent academic controversies such as the Harvard episode involving Carole Hooven.
← Back to All Ideas