State Capture of Science

Updated: 2026.01.08 21D ago 2 sources
Authoritarian or politicized institutions can replace empirical methods with ideologically driven doctrines and enforce them through personnel, funding, and legal power, producing large‑scale policy failures and repression of dissenting experts. Modern democracies need concrete institutional protections—transparent peer review, tenure safeguards, international verification, and published robustness maps—to prevent similar outcomes. — This reframes contemporary fights over research funding, regulatory independence, and pandemic/technology policy as not only normative disputes but as safeguards against institutional capture with real humanitarian costs.

Sources

Japan's Nuclear Watchdog Halts Plant's Reactor Safety Screening Over Falsified Data
BeauHD 2026.01.08 90% relevant
The Hamaoka episode concretely echoes the 'state capture of science' theme: corporate or institutional pressures (here a power utility) distorted safety‑critical evidence, forcing the regulator to restart evaluation and exposing how non‑scientific incentives can corrupt technical assessments that undergird public policy on energy and safety.
The Disastrous Effects of Lysenkoism on Soviet Agriculture | Encyclopedia.com
2026.01.04 100% relevant
The article documents Trofim Lysenko’s influence on the Soviet Central Committee, his rejection of Mendelian genetics, promoted seed‑treatment programs, and the resulting repression and agricultural disaster.
← Back to All Ideas