Stop Valuing Suffering Over Health

Updated: 2025.08.19 2M ago 2 sources
The essay argues that public fury at embryo screening and AI 'completing' a grief-infused artwork reveals a bias toward romanticizing suffering and tragedy. It claims that progress often makes culture feel 'shallower' by removing sources of pain, and that society should accept this tradeoff to reduce harm. The frame challenges moral objections that seek to preserve suffering for meaning or authenticity. — If a 'suffering premium' shapes norms and policy, it could slow adoption of genetic and medical technologies that substantially cut disease and disability.

Sources

Can You "Choose" Your Baby's Ancestry? The Science of Embryo Selection
Davide Piffer 2025.08.19 50% relevant
Public criticism of embryo screening often conjures dystopias like parents 'choosing ethnicity'; this piece shows, with simulations, that ancestry selection is tightly constrained—useful for reframing embryo screening as targeted health risk reduction rather than ethnic engineering.
Toward a Shallower Future
Noah Smith 2025.08.17 100% relevant
Noor Siddiqui’s Orchid IVF screening tweet and the Keith Haring 'Unfinished Painting' AI completion controversy on X/Twitter.
← Back to All Ideas