Stop Waiting for UFO Proof

Updated: 2025.08.21 2M ago 2 sources
Hanson argues decades of sightings have yielded little decisive progress and that further reports are unlikely to materially change our decisions. He proposes a four‑step pipeline: estimate per‑report probabilities, aggregate by category, infer alien traits from theory, then pick actions (broadcasting, defenses, search). The UFO community’s taboo on steps 3–4 has stalled policy despite sufficient uncertainty to act. — This reframes UFOs as a decision‑making problem under persistent uncertainty, pushing institutions to do expected‑value policy rather than endlessly seek consensus proof.

Sources

Decide Now; We Won’t Know Much More Later Re UFOs
Robin Hanson 2025.08.21 100% relevant
Robin Hanson’s four‑stage framework and his claim that the UFO/UAP community fixates on data collection (steps 1–2) while avoiding inference and decision (steps 3–4).
Pre-Sputnik Earth-Orbit Glints
Robin Hanson 2025.08.17 80% relevant
Hanson presents quantitative evidence (106,339 transients with a 21.9-sigma sunlight–shadow effect at ~42,000 km) consistent with pre-Sputnik orbital reflectors, strengthening his argument to move from seeking perfect proof to acting under uncertainty.
← Back to All Ideas