STV Needs Majority Coalitions

Updated: 2025.10.14 8D ago 1 sources
Portland’s experiment with single transferable vote and a larger council shows that proportional systems still require disciplined majority coalitions to govern. Absent party structures or coalition agreements, a faction can deadlock committees, agendas, and basic council work, risking a public backlash against PR itself. — It reframes electoral reform debates by warning that changing vote rules without building coalition and committee governance can backfire and discredit proportional representation nationwide.

Sources

Portland’s Troubled Proportional Representation Experiment
Jack Santucci 2025.10.14 100% relevant
Portland’s council is split between a coordinated Progressive caucus and a fractured opposition, spurning committee delegation and even pro bono governance help, producing visible gridlock.
← Back to All Ideas