Substack as Canon Maker

Updated: 2026.04.28 2H ago 1 sources
Legacy outlets like the New York Times still solicit expert judgments, but independent platform authors (Substack newsletters, podcasts) are increasingly the visible venue where those judgments are published, debated, and canonized. When high‑profile contributors withhold material from legacy institutions and publish on platforms, the platforms themselves become rival arbiters of cultural status. — This shift changes who gets to define 'greatness' in culture, decentralizes cultural authority, and alters how reputations, markets, and institutional power form around artists.

Sources

The NY Times Asked Me to Pick the Greatest Living American Songwriters
Ted Gioia 2026.04.28 100% relevant
Jake Silverstein's invitation from the New York Times Magazine, the author's refusal to let the Times publish his ballot, and the later NYT list that diverged substantially (only five overlaps) exemplify the dynamic.
← Back to All Ideas