Tacit Management Over Consulting Playbooks

Updated: 2025.09.09 1M ago 4 sources
Rickover warned that management can’t be learned from glossy frameworks and that no procedural tweak will 'fix' complex systems. High performance in dangerous technologies comes from selecting motivated operators and drilling practical skills through apprenticeship‑like training. — It challenges government and corporate reliance on consulting templates, arguing capacity comes from building operator cultures rather than drafting new processes.

Sources

The Good Apprentice
Matthew B. Crawford 2025.09.09 70% relevant
Polanyi’s model of learning by apprenticeship and tacit imitation mirrors Rickover’s emphasis on selecting and drilling operators over procedural 'best practices,' arguing that real mastery depends on embodied, mentor‑guided knowledge rather than codified checklists.
Nine Rules for Managing Humans Managing Nuclear Reactors
2025.08.25 100% relevant
Rickover’s 1978 OPM Management essay and his Congressional testimony after Three Mile Island emphasizing personal interviews and continual practical training.
The Bitter Lesson versus The Garbage Can
Ethan Mollick 2025.07.28 55% relevant
The article’s process‑map anecdote shows leaders’ control is often illusory and procedures are improvised, echoing Rickover’s claim that glossy frameworks don’t run complex systems—operator judgment and practical methods do. It extends this to AI: instead of painstaking process engineering, general AI may work around organizational messiness.
REVIEW: Cræft, by Alexander Langlands
Jane Psmith 2025.03.24 56% relevant
Langlands’s 'cræft'—embodied mastery that unites know‑how and character—parallels Rickover’s emphasis on selecting and drilling elite operators over abstract process fixes; both argue real capability comes from practiced human skill rather than managerial formalism.
← Back to All Ideas