Nominal increases in manufacturing shipments tied to AI‑related demand can be erased once you adjust for producer prices; tariffs and price effects are acting as a policy-level offset to any underlying demand boom. Smith shows industrial production and inflation‑adjusted gross manufacturing output remain essentially flat despite headlines about a 'stealth' revival.
— This reframes policy debates by showing that trade measures (tariffs) can neutralize sectoral demand shocks, so claims of a manufacturing comeback should be tested with real, price‑adjusted metrics before informing policy.
Noah Smith
2026.04.21
100% relevant
Noah Smith's review of manufacturing shipments, the producer price index for manufacturing, and industrial production figures used to rebut Greg Ip's 'stealth manufacturing boom' claim; Smith explicitly credits tariffs as canceling tailwinds.
← Back to All Ideas